Common Mistakes of First-Time Pet Owners

Written by Everypaw
Updated 19 Nov 2026
A beagle puppy in first-time pet owner mistakes

A cat, dog or rabbit can be a great addition to your home with all their fur and cuddles. A new furry member of the family is bounding in, ready to disrupt with their undoubtedly adorable looks. There's no doubt it seems like a good idea at the time, and it can be. You just need to make sure, as a first-time pet owner, you're as prepared as possible.

Ask any seasoned pet owner, and they'll tell you the first one isn't always smooth sailing. So, with the help of our resident expert, Dr Anna Foreman, we asked her the all-important questions about the most common mistakes first-time pet owners make.

What are the top three mistakes pet owners make?

1. Not keeping microchip details up to date

In her veterinary practice, one of Dr Anna's most common findings is owners not updating microchip details. She often finds outdated contact details when scanning a lost dog's microchip or cat's microchip, such as an old address or phone number.

"This usually occurs when an animal is rehomed privately (not through a charity) or taken home from a breeder, as owners may be unaware it’s now their responsibility to update the details on the microchip."

"It's important to make sure to regularly check the owner details on an animal's microchip and insurance policy - at least once a year. Everypaw Pet Insurance includes additional benefits to help find your pet if they go missing, but if you don't keep details up to date, reuniting owners with their pets can take much longer."

2. Not restraining your dog in a car

"While this is less common now due to fines having been put into place, we still do occasionally see animals involved in road traffic accidents from inside the car, with head injuries being particularly common. In more complex cases, and from my decade of veterinary experience, treatment can cost between £10,000 and £12,000, especially where diagnostics, hospitalisation, advanced imaging and specialist surgery are required."

"Owners should make sure their animals are secured within a crate, within the boot, or by a harness to a seatbelt port when travelling in the car to prevent accidents."

According to the Highway Code (57), dogs and other animals must be restrained in a moving vehicle. If an animal is found not restrained and it leads to careless driving or driver distraction, pet owners could face up to £5,000 in fines and up to nine points on your licence.

3. Not keeping up with vaccines and flea and worming treatment

"A flea and worm infestation could cost over £800 to treat (up to a 5,000% increase in vet costs). If an animal becomes critically unwell from a parasite infestation (flea anaemia in kittens, or a lungworm infection in dogs), critical care for these patients can amount to over £800 for the costs of hospitalisation, fluids, repeat bloods and medications. If specialist intervention is needed, this cost could be in the thousands."

"Owners also tend to forget about yearly vaccinations after an animal’s initial primary course, or are under the impression they either do not need further vaccinations, or need them less frequently than required. With practice management systems now facilitating reminders, this is becoming less common."

"However, for GDPR reasons, vets have to ask owners if they would like to receive email or text reminders, which owners usually associate with promotions and news rather than reminders, and tend to decline. If this is the case, owners should set their own reminders for flea/worm treatment and vaccinations."

Are there any other common mistakes you see first-time pet owners making?

Not researching the type of animal and breed before adopting

"Many potential owners do not realise the husbandry differences and financial/time commitments between different types of pets, and indeed different breeds within a species. Many incorrectly assume smaller pets require less space and are cheaper to maintain, and that all breeds are the same. Dog breeds particularly vary widely in their needs and personality!"

Not realising the difference when adopting a puppy or kitten vs an older dog or cat

"Each life stage comes with different needs." It's important to understand that when you adopt a pet, especially a young one, they need attention and training. The same can be said for an older pet; you need to be patient and let them get used to their new surroundings, and not punish them if accidents happen.

Adopting pets from abroad also comes with a new range of challenges; the pet will need to learn new commands in a different language. Plus, some of their behaviours, like escapism or scavenging, could be totally normal for them, especially if they've been rescued from the streets.

Owners being unaware that certain conditions can be related rather than isolated issues

"Owners are also unaware that certain conditions are related to one another rather than isolated issues. For example, ear infections often have a strong link to atopic dermatitis (allergies). Because of this lack of understanding, claims are sometimes declined or exclusions applied, which can be misunderstood by owners as insurers avoiding a payment, when in reality, there is an underlying medical connection between conditions."

"It’s not common knowledge that ‘shopping around’ and changing insurers can be detrimental to an animal in the long term. Policies rarely cover pre-existing conditions, and so changing a policy may lead to a condition being excluded and not being able to be paid out for, losing an owner money in the long term."

What advice would you give to pet owners to avoid invalidating their insurance claims?

"An owner should make sure they have a full understanding of their pet insurance policy. Most insurers have guides to pet insurance on their websites to help owners understand the different types and what is (and what is not) covered. Policy terms and conditions may seem boring; however, they contain vital information."

"An owner should also make sure their details are kept up to date regularly (both at the vets and on their policy) so that everything matches. Simple things like an animal’s breed or age not being consistent from an insurance policy to a vet’s notes can affect a policy."

What are the top things people need to consider before getting a pet?

How much time do you have for a pet?

"If a potential owner leads a busy lifestyle, they may not have the time for a pet. Pets require love and attention – if this cannot be provided, then an animal can become depressed, with this even leading to physical illness."

Can you afford a pet?

"Pets can be expensive. Even if an owner has pet insurance, the costs of routine treatment (such as vaccinations and flea/worming) and husbandry items (such as food) need to be taken into consideration. There is a large difference between the costs for different pets and breeds within this too – for example, a Great Dane will cost far more to feed than a Chihuahua!"

Does everyone at home want a pet?

"Ensuring everybody within the house is on board with getting the new pet – everybody’s opinions and needs should be taken into consideration."

What surprising things do people not think about before getting a pet?

Who will look after your pet if you go away?

"Potential owners often do not consider who will take care of their animal if they are unavailable – for example, if they are unwell or go away on holiday. They should check with friends and family before taking on a new animal so that even in unforeseen circumstances, a pet can be cared for."

What happens if the pet develops a long-term health condition?

"Potential owners also do not consider whether, if an animal were to get a long-term health condition. Would they be able to provide appropriate care for that animal? For example, if a pet develops diabetes, would they be able to inject their pet with insulin, or if their pet develops an eye ulcer, would they be able to apply drops four times a day to their eyes?"

What are your top tips for keeping vet bills down?

"Speak openly with your vet practice if there are financial constraints for veterinary care for your pet. Make sure to always ask for estimates of costs, and to keep asking for an updated bill through the course of treatment so there are no surprises at the end."

"Pet insurance can help support an owner with the costs of veterinary care; However ultimately, it is an owner’s responsibility to be able to pay for veterinary care for their pet."

"Owning a pet is a luxury, and so before purchasing or adopting an animal, an owner must be prepared to pay for their ongoing veterinary care - this can be expensive."

Dr Anna Foreman

Everypaw Vet Dr Anna Foreman

Dr Anna Foreman is a UK-registered veterinary surgeon with over 9 years’ experience caring for dogs, cats and small companion animals. Anna has worked with Everypaw for over eight years and supports our customers and us with her knowledge and expertise.

Everypaw Pet Insurance

Everypaw's Pet Insurance comes with 24/7 unlimited access to vets and vet nurses that can help with your pet's health, care, nutrition and behaviour. So you can rest assured your pet will be well looked after.

Start a Quote